BMI Supply Design Competition Awards history, 2008-2019
2008
- Best Graphic Design: Little Shop of Horrors – Charles King – Geneva Theatre Guild
- Best Costume Design: Aladdin Jr. – AErin Lanphear – Geneva Theatre Guild
- Best Scenic Design: The Dragon – Navroz Dabu – Appleseed Productions
- Certificate of Merit: Meet Me in St. Louis – Costume Design Team – Circle Theatre Players
2009
- Best Graphic Design: Cats – Poster, Cassandra Angerosa – Hartford Players Youth Theatre
- Certificate of Merit: Cats – Costume Design, Donna Korie and Cassandra Angerosa – Hartford Players Youth Theatre
- Certificate of Merit: Cats – Wig and Make-up Design, William Lanfear – Hartford Players Youth Theatre
2010
- Best Overall Design: To Kill a Mockingbird – Scenic Design, Navroz Dabu – Appleseed Productions
- Best Production Design: Knuckles – Artistic Staff – Harlequin Productions of Cayuga Community College
- Best Special Effects Design for the Black Light Fish: Seussical, Jr. – AErin Lanphear – Geneva Theatre Guild Youth Theatre
- Best Graphic Design: Rent – Charles King – Geneva Theatre Guild
2011
- Best Graphic Design: Into the Woods – Charles King and Steve Duprey – Geneva Theatre Guild
- Best Scenic Design: In the Blood – Ed Hallborg – Forum Players of Genesee Community College
- Best Overall Design: When I Come to My Senses, I’m Alive – Robert John Andrusko – Harlequin Productions of Cayuga Community College
2012
- Best Overall Design: Titanic, The Musical – Rob Sharman – Everyone's Theatre Company
- Best Special Effects: Godspell – Puppets, AErin Lanphear – Seneca Community Players
- Best Costume Design: Club Hell – Mathew Ryan Limerick – Harlequin Productions of Cayuga Community College
- Best Scenic Design: God’s Favorite – Ed Hallborg – Forum Players of Genesee Community College
- Best Graphic Design: Titanic, The Musical – Eric Pray – Everyone's Theatre Company
- Certificate of Merit: Avenue Q – Puppets, Larry Ann Evans – Geneva Theatre Guild
2013
- Best Overall Design: Love in the Insecurity Zone – Director, Bob Frame; Scenic, Robert John Andrusko; Lighting, Brad McLean; Costumes, Matthew Ryan Limerick; Video, Mark Romig – Harlequin Productions of Cayuga Community College
- Best Technical Design: Game Show – Michael Sharp – Rome Community Theater
- Best Sound Design: The Woman in Black – John Harvey – Troy Civic Theatre
- Best Graphic Design: An Evening in the Black Box – David Grayson and Cynthia Appleton – Wyoming County Bicentennial Singers
- Best Costume Design: Guys and Dolls – Kristen Lanphear – Seneca Community Players and Geneva Theatre Guild
- Best Set Design: Hamlet Cha Cha Cha – Navroz Dabu – Appleseed Productions
2014
- Best Graphic Design: The Sisters Rosensweig – Louie Podlaski – Rochester’s Black Sheep Theatre
- Best Scenic Design: Carmilla – Virginia Fennessy – Harlequin Productions of Cayuga Community College
2015
- Best Overall Design: The Importance of Being Earnest – Costumes, Sandra Cimmino – Classic Theatre Guild
- Best Graphic Design: Zero to Infinity – Louie Podlaski – Harlequin Productions of Cayuga Community College
- Best Props Design: Musical Comedy Murders of 1940 – Terri Gadsby – Auburn Players Community Theatre
- Best Scenic Design: Losing Our Heads: The Guillotine Play – Robert John Andrusko – Harlequin Productions of Cayuga Community College
- Best Production Design: Musical Comedy Murders of 1940 – Virginia Fennessy – Auburn Players Community Theatre
2016
- Best Overall Design: Billy Budd – Director, Bob Frame; Scenic, Robert John Andrusko; Costumes, Virginia Fennessy; Lights, Brad McLean; Sound, Chris Yeckel – Harlequin Productions of Cayuga Community College
- Best Graphic Design: A Country Christmas in the Grange – Cynthia Appleton and David Grayson – Wyoming County Bicentennial Singers
- Best Props Design: Moon Over Buffalo – Terri Gadsby – Auburn Players Community Theatre
- Best Costume Design: The Wizard of Oz – Sandra Cimmino – Foothill Family Productions
2017
- Best Overall Design: The Giver – Scenic Design, Navroz Dabu – Auburn Players Community Theatre
- Best Graphic Design: Crossroads – Adam Williams – Harlequin Productions of Cayuga Community College
- Best Technical Design: Haunted Theater Tours – Jim Schmidt – Sullivan County Dramatic Workshop
2018
- Best Overall Design: Alice in Black and White – Costume Design, Virginia Fennessy – Harlequin Productions of Cayuga Community College
- Best Props Design: Alice in Black and White – Terri Fox – Harlequin Productions of Cayuga Community College
- Certificate of Merit for Inventive and Resourceful Prop Design: Sketch – The Musical – Terri Fox, Auburn Players Community Theatre
2019
- Best Overall Design: L’il Abner – Props, Terri Fox – Auburn Players Community Theatre
